Welcome to old and new friends who are interested in discussing Cajun and other diatonic accordions, along with some occasional lagniappe....



CAJUN ACCORDION DISCUSSION GROUP

 

General Forum
Start a New Topic 
Author
Comment
Horner steel bronze reeds

Are these good reeds if found for right price and how do they sound and hold up.
Appreciate inputs and comment

Re: Horner steel bronze reeds

You mean the reed itself is bronze? Are they old? I didn't think anyone made them anymore, but maybe they do. The very old accordions had some sort of brass/bronze reed. I've heard (no personal experience) than they are not very loud and don't hold a tune well, and break easily, which is why everyone I know of today makes steel reeds.

Re: Horner steel bronze reeds

I wonder if he means steel reeds with the brass/bronze reed plates?

Using these adds a lot of weight to the accordion.
(brass being quite a bit heavier than Aluminum.)

DP

Re: Horner steel bronze reeds

Could be, but hadn't heard of them in Hohner. Even being a lot thinner bases, they are noticeably heavier for even a half set like I put in mine. Lot's of different opinions on this, and probably depends a lot on the accordion itself, but some say they are louder, some say not, the ones I've installed seem clearer toned and quicker to respond, but others say little difference. They are usually quite a bit more expensive.

Re: Horner steel bronze reeds

There from the twenties yeh there kind of old. How much are the worth and is worth the trouble of using them over other new brands

Re: Horner steel bronze reeds

I'd say they're worth whatever a cheap paper weight would be.

Re: Horner steel bronze reeds

I actually saw an old hohner from the 20's, or perhaps even earlier, a few days ago with the "Steel Brass Reeds" stamped on the inside face plate. If that's what you're talking about I would stay far away. The reeds inside were all on four long plates as opposed to individual reeds and the reeds themselves did not put out much volume at all and looked very fragile compared to the old blue steel or modern reeds.

Re: Horner steel bronze reeds

I've got 2 in my shop like that right now, they're novelties. What's odd abou those old reeds on the single plates, is the base side has as good a volume as todays reeds, but the treble is very weak. I wouldn't buy any reeds like that to put in a good accordion. Might be worth fixing up an old accordion because they have a neat old sound, but don't expect much performance.

Re: Horner steel bronze reeds

Some afficianados of Hohners consider the single zinc plates with steel/bronze reeds to have the best sound.

Second best are the same reeds on individual zinc plates.. rare

Third.. the same reeds on aluminum plates marked "H"



Jamey Hall's most excellent Cajun Accordion Music Theory

Brett's all new Cajun Accordion Music Theory for all keys!

LFR1.gif - 1092 Bytes The April 2011 Dewey Balfa Cajun & Creole Heritage Week

augusta.gif - 6841 Bytes

Listen to Some GREAT Music While You Surf the Net!!
The BEST Radio Station on the Planet!