I carry mine in a soft case and it fits under the seat of every plane I've been on including puddle jumpers. Hope this helps.
I just got back from a trip to/from Louisiana from SFO. Had a rather large fiddle case with triangle and striker in the case pocket and an accordion in a soft case as carry-ons, plus a small purse. Didn't have a problem at all - well, it's no joke about being asked to play a song at security, but that's more a curiosity thing, not a security concern. Oh, and on the flight from Lafayette to Houston on the way back, there was a band from Mali beginning their trip home from Festival International and they had some really big instruments all as carry-ons and had no problem - each instrument ended up strapped in by seatbelt in empty seats. I wouldn't want to check an instrument through as luggage because of handling concerns and temperature exposure.
Can't answer your question about 9-button vs. 10-button accordions.
Hi Leslie! I don't know what kind of case you have, but I always carried mine on in the soft case I have. I DID check it once, in the soft case IN a suitcase, and it was fine after I warmed it up a bit. Something happens in the cold down under the plane, just like in cold weather, where the reeds stick or something and you need to play it a bit to get it to stop honking and making terrible wheezing sounds. My dad used to check his in anvil cases, and never had any problems, but now he carries them on if he can. If you have a soft case and can't carry it on because of your camping gear, I suggest you gate-check it, so at least it will go right on top of everything else.
Then again, I don't know what kind of accordion you have. Cajun accordions can hold up to anything, including someone my dad's size standing on them.
He made that one specially for standing on it I guess?
Was it a red one?
I have one of your dad's, Sarah, and sure wouldn't dare to stand on it. Too precious
About soft cases, I have a soft case for records Disc Jockeys use. A cajun accordion fits in exactly. For the stops I made an extra protection. I can even leave them in playing position. Perfect and heath protected as well. I think the size is o.k. Price was around 50 euro, so not so cheap as the Igloo brand fish bait coolers.
No, you can totally stand on it! (Please--not for performance tactics but for demonstration of their strength only ) Yep, the red one. Saw the vid? With the sheep ____?
That soft case was WAY expensive. The ones my dad sells are similar, though, I'm guessing, but I don't know the price. They're made by Peavey for DJ equipment or something like that and come with these velco-edged pieces that he tapes together. You put that on top of the accordion once you put it in the bag and that protects the stops.
I'm still looking for a case for my D accordion. But Importing from the US is also expensive (unless it can be folded).
By the way, if you wish I'll send you a picture of my case.
just wanted to pass along some info related to travel with an instrument...
Not sure if it was just that one airline I was on, but the last time I traveled with my anvil case, I could not fit it under the seat in front of me. I just sort of hid the fact that it wasn't fitting very well, and made like my knee in my face was really comfortable, but I wasn't going to put it anywhere else (not sure if it fits in overhead).