Re: Re: Re: Re: Thoughts on Construction accordion frame joints
I love the aesthetic effect of exposed and rounded wood corners, but my Bon Cajun has spent some time on the bar room floor while I reached for my 'tit fer or guitar, so I'm glad for its metal corners.
Some of us have it in us to treat instruments with tenderness at all times, but some of us get distracted too easily...
also exist,
see link #1 (same link as the bellows)
Why make an accordion h-bomb proof when the flappers bend, the bellows kan leak, the reeds fall off in summer and the player lost the key of the safe where it's in?
I have never had an accordeon where the levers bent the bellows went bad or the reeds fell off and I don;t lock them up
I guess I am form another world.
I have a 1959 Guild M-20 Guitar that aside form a few tiny dings looks like a new instrument
I mhave a 1977 Strat hardtail that aside form a few button dents on the back looks new
I have an 1880's 2 row accordeon that shiolf look beat but looks quite good
Most of the "high end" accordeojn mkaers round their corners
among them would be
Gaillard
Briggs
Kinkora
Castagnari
Melodie
No metal required
A spline dmitre precludes the use of an inner corner block
I find no need for an inner corner block using a proper jopint
But a mitre with a block is fine
Considering Gaillard was first and "ebiniste" joiner/cabinet maker I have no doubt he may be using a short spline like a miniature biscuit or he could be using a blind dovetail
but that would be over kill
I have not looked inside a Gaillard to see if there is a corner block
He is a very clever guy and a fine wood worker but also somewhat conservative.. I am sure whatever he uses is "just right" for the job
So, I just leave it to the builders to decide. And I have the choice to buy or not.
(btw, and off topic: Gaillard makes very nice instruments. But I like the old ones that have an other sound. Do you know why?)
Gus,
I assume that you are talking about the older Gaillard boxes. I also love the sound of the four-voice boxes that he used to make (he does still make a one-row, four voice). I wish that there were more Gaillards around!
-Andy
That's a cool looking one row with four stops. Years ago, I played a weekend music camp at Chesapeake Bay. There was a guy there with a Canadian built box that had corners that were rounder than that and the keyboard was ergonomic. For years, I thought it was a Melodie, but I have not seen another one like it.
The Mélodie has rounded corners, but so do Simard's boxes. Normand Miron build ONE box with rounded corners, which he sold to an amateur player who may have since sold it -- it was a great box but with a rather strange keyboard (hard to describe).
-Andy