. . . have to agree that D is not louder .. but higher pitched and " shriller ".
Instrumentals.. fast one.. sound faster and cleaner in D.. Conjunto players will gladly rip a fast Polka in D on a ADG box to show off their virtuoso skills..
The D is like high gear.. or Soprano singing.. cuts through through the backround noise. Little to do with loud .. other than a perceived piercing tone.
Most tuners follow this logic as well.. faster the vibe, sharper to the sound, and D is faster and higher and sharper..
Well 3 years ago I didn't know I could sing. I couldn't carry a note or sing on key, didn't even know what it meant to do so. I started taking lessons and found that you can teach old dogs new tricks, you may not want to see it performing them too often but you can you teach them.
Le Piquant